Banking liability

Bank fraud lawyer in Spain: claiming your money back from the bank

If you did not authorise the payment, the bank should in principle refund you, and to refuse it has to prove your gross negligence. Two things weigh heavily on the outcome: how much time has passed and what was done in the first few days.
I am José Ángel Soria, a lawyer registered with the Balearic Bar (ICAIB 5971). Almost 30 years of professional experience. My background includes investment banking, in derivatives, at Goldman Sachs (New York) and Deutsche Bank (London), and a spell at American Express (Madrid). My office is in Palma and I work remotely across Spain. I handle your matter myself.

Registered lawyer

ICAIB no. 5971

Balearic Bar Association

Initial consultation

30 min · €200, VAT incl.

Video call, in person or phone

Where

Palma and all of Spain

In person, video call or phone

Languages

English and Spanish

I work in both

What does the law say when your account is emptied?

The rule is Royal Decree-law 19/2018 on payment services, which brings the EU's PSD2 directive into Spanish law. Three rules are enough to find your bearings:

  • The bank refunds first. If a payment is not authorised, the bank must refund it immediately and, at the latest, by the end of the next business day after it noticed it or was notified. The only exception is where it has reasonable grounds to suspect fraud by the customer and reports those grounds in writing to the Bank of Spain (article 45.1).
  • The bank has to prove its case. If you deny authorising a payment, the bank must show that it was authenticated, accurately recorded and entered in the accounts (article 44.1). A record that your credentials were used is not, on its own, enough to prove that you authorised the payment or were negligent (article 44.2), and proving fraud or gross negligence on your part is also the bank's job (article 44.3).
  • You bear all the loss if you acted fraudulently or with gross negligence. If the bank proves it, the account holder bears all losses (article 46.1). That is why the real argument is almost always whether there was gross negligence, not whether the credentials were correct.

For example, imagine someone who, on a Friday evening after a fake call from "the bank", has three transfers made for a total of 14,800 euros. They tell the bank on Saturday. The bank says the credentials were correct and refuses to refund anything. Under the law, it should have refunded the 14,800 euros by Monday at the latest, unless it reported reasonable grounds to suspect customer fraud in writing to the Bank of Spain. If the same person had waited 14 months to tell the bank, the bank could refuse to put it right because the thirteen months in article 43.1 had passed, even though the fraud was identical. The difference between telling the bank on Saturday and telling it after fourteen months could be 14,800 euros. My view: if there is a payment you do not recognise, tell the bank in writing the same day and keep proof. Everything else can be sorted out later.

Which kinds of fraud do I handle?

  • Phishing, SIM swapping, Bizum and fake bank calls. A third party executes the payment with your details, sometimes by tricking you into handing them over. The starting point is the refund in article 45.1.
  • Investment and crypto scams ("pig butchering"). Here you order the transfer yourself, deceived by a fake platform or person. There is no automatic refund. Consent was given, but it may be flawed, and the argument against the bank is built differently, case by case.
  • CEO fraud. The victim is a company, and responsibility is shared between company, bank and director.

How much time do I have?

  • 13 months from the debit to tell the bank about an unauthorised payment, and without undue delay once you know of it (article 43.1).
  • 5 years for a court claim against the bank in contract (article 1964.2, Civil Code).
  • 1 year for a claim in non-contractual liability, for example against the fraudster, from when the injured person knew (article 1968.2).

The 13-month period is for telling the bank. The time limit for suing is a different one.

How do we work?

  1. A 30-minute consultation

    (200 euros including VAT, deducted from my fees if you instruct me). I review the account history, what you have said to the bank or platform and any reply already received.

  2. Assessment

    Whether it is an immediate-refund case, a scam where you consented, or a mix, and which argument best supports the claim. If the case is weak, I tell you before you spend more.

  3. Written demand

    A letter to the bank demanding the refund, which records the date and the bank's position. Where appropriate, a complaint to the bank's customer service and to the Bank of Spain.

  4. Court, if needed

    A claim against the bank, with the court representative (procurador) who is needed.

Frequently asked questions

Does the bank always have to refund money lost to fraud?

If you did not authorise the payment, it must refund immediately and, at the latest, by the end of the next business day after notification (article 45.1, Royal Decree-law 19/2018). It can refuse at the outset only if it has reasonable grounds to suspect customer fraud and reports them in writing to the Bank of Spain. Afterwards, if it proves fraud or gross negligence, the account holder bears the loss (articles 44.3 and 46.1).

Can the bank refuse to refund me if I gave out my own codes?

Arguing only that the credentials were correct is not enough to prove you were negligent (article 44.2). The bank must prove fraud or gross negligence on your part (article 44.3). If it does, you bear the loss. Each case is decided on its facts and on the record of messages and calls.

What is the difference between phishing and an investment scam?

In phishing, a third party makes the payment with your details, and the law protects an immediate refund. In an investment scam you order the transfer, deceived. Consent existed but may be flawed, and the argument against the bank is different.

How long do I have to claim?

13 months from the debit to tell the bank (article 43.1, Royal Decree-law 19/2018) and 5 years for a court claim in contract (article 1964.2, Civil Code). The sooner you act, the easier it is to rebuild the evidence.

Do you take cases outside Mallorca?

Yes. My office is in Palma and I handle matters across Spain. The claim to the bank and to the Bank of Spain is made remotely. If there is a court claim, we look at where to file it.

Do I need a lawyer to claim from the bank?

Not to claim from the bank or the Bank of Spain. For a court claim it depends on the amount: in oral proceedings (juicio verbal) of up to 2,000 euros you can appear without a lawyer or court representative, and above that both are required (articles 23.2.1 and 31.2.1, Civil Procedure Act).

How much does a lawyer cost for a bank fraud claim?

The first consultation lasts 30 minutes and costs 200 euros including VAT. If we go ahead, fees are agreed in writing in an engagement letter before work starts, with the amount or the basis for calculating it and what a costs order could mean.

Book your consultation

A 30-minute consultation costs 200 euros including VAT, deducted from my fees if you instruct me. The sooner, the better.
Book a consultation · €200

You pay when you book, by card (Stripe), in the Cal.com calendar. You get an invoice. If I cannot take your matter, I refund the amount. How we use your data: privacy policy.

Not sure yet? Tell me about your case by email and I will reply within two working days, at no cost.

Book a consultation · €200