Property law
You Signed a Spanish Deposit Contract. Now You Want Out. Here's What Happens

You signed a Spanish deposit contract. A few days later, something changed — another property, a failed survey, cold feet. You assume you can walk away. You are wrong. In Spain, the type of deposit contract you signed determines whether you lose 10% of the purchase price, face a court claim, or have no exit at all.
My phone rang on a Thursday afternoon. A British couple — let's call them the Hendersons — had been in Mallorca two weeks earlier looking at properties. They found something they loved: a reformed farmhouse outside Pollença, asking price €890,000. The estate agent was charming and efficient. She produced a document at the kitchen table, explained it was "standard," and within the hour they had signed and transferred €89,000 from their UK account.
Back in London, the surveyor they eventually consulted raised serious questions about the structure. The Hendersons called me wanting to know how to get their money back. The answer was not straightforward — because nobody had told them what kind of contract they had actually signed.
Three contracts, three completely different outcomes
The contrato de arras is not one document. It is a category that contains three legally distinct instruments. Most foreign buyers treat them as interchangeable. Spanish courts do not.
The three types at a glance
| Type | Legal basis | Buyer pulls out | Seller pulls out | Risk level |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arras penitenciales | Art. 1454 CC | Loses deposit (typically 10%) | Returns double the deposit | Moderate — clear exit cost |
| Arras confirmatorias | Arts. 1101 & 1124 CC | Faces court claim for full damages or forced completion | Faces court claim for full damages or forced completion | High — no exit by forfeiture |
| Arras penales | Arts. 1152–1154 CC | Loses deposit AND may face enforcement | Returns double AND may face enforcement | High — penalty plus enforcement |
What estate agents do not explain
The estate agent is not a lawyer. She is not required to be. In Spain, it is perfectly legal for an agent to produce a pre-printed arras contract and invite you to sign it at the kitchen table. What the agent rarely explains — because it is not in her interest to slow the process — is that this document has immediate legal consequences that cannot be undone by a phone call.
I have seen this pattern consistently: a buyer treats the deposit as a reservation — something like an option to buy, cancelable on request. Spanish law does not recognise that concept in this context. Once you sign and transfer, the deposit contract is binding from that moment.
The most common traps
- 1 No type specified — defaults to confirmatorias The contract says "deposit" or "on account of the purchase price" but says nothing about withdrawal rights or Article 1454. Courts read this as confirmatorias. You cannot buy your way out for €89,000. You may owe the full €890,000 or equivalent damages.
- 2 Signed under time pressure without independent legal review The agent says there is another buyer. You sign to secure the property. You have not had the contract reviewed. There are no protective clauses for failed finance, negative survey results, or planning issues. None of these automatically entitle you to withdraw.
- 3 Finance contingency missing If you need a mortgage and the bank refuses, this does not automatically void the contract. A finance contingency clause must be expressly included. Without it, the seller may retain your deposit even if a Spanish bank refuses your loan.
- 4 Survey or due diligence not listed as a condition A structural survey revealing problems does not automatically entitle you to terminate unless the contract includes a specific clause making the sale conditional on a satisfactory survey. Without that clause, you have signed regardless of what the surveyor finds.
- 5 Planning irregularities not discovered before signing Mallorca has specific rural land regulations. A property with unlicensed extensions, pool installations, or guest houses may be legally problematic in ways that are not visible during a visit. The arras contract does not pause while you investigate. Signing commits you to the property as it stands.
What happened to the Hendersons
When I reviewed their contract, it contained a standard phrase: the deposit was paid "a cuenta del precio" — on account of the price. No reference to Article 1454. No withdrawal clause. No finance contingency. No survey condition.
Under Spanish law, that contract was almost certainly arras confirmatorias. The seller could have sued them for the full purchase price, or at minimum for damages substantially exceeding the €89,000 deposit.
We negotiated. The seller had a motivated buyer behind them and did not want litigation either. The Hendersons recovered €55,000 of their deposit through a negotiated settlement — painful, but better than a court proceeding that could have cost them significantly more. Their solicitor in London had told them the contract was "pretty standard." It was. That is precisely the problem.
Before signing any Spanish deposit contract, verify three things: (1) the contract explicitly states arras penitenciales with reference to Article 1454 of the Civil Code; (2) there is a finance contingency clause if you need a mortgage; (3) there is a due diligence period or survey condition before the deposit becomes non-refundable. If any of these are missing, the contract needs to be amended before you sign — not after.
My view as an independent lawyer
The estate agent is not your lawyer. The notary is not your lawyer. The developer's legal advisor is not your lawyer. In a transaction of several hundred thousand euros, paying for an independent review of the arras contract — before you sign, before you transfer — is not a precaution. It is the only rational decision. I have spent more hours than I care to count trying to recover money from contracts that should never have been signed as drafted. The conversation I would rather have is the one that happens before the document reaches the table.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions from foreign buyers — answers that matter before you sign
How I Can Help You
I review arras contracts before you sign — and I advise on your options after signing. Based in Palma de Mallorca, I work with English-speaking buyers across Mallorca and Ibiza. One conversation at the right moment can save you considerably more than it costs.
Book a 30-minute consultation30-minute initial consultation: €200, VAT included.
You pay when you book, by card (Stripe), in the Cal.com calendar. You get an invoice. If I cannot take your matter, I refund the amount. How we use your data: privacy policy.
Articles 1101, 1124, Código Civil español — arras confirmatorias and contractual breach.
Articles 1152–1154, Código Civil español — arras penales / penalty clauses.
STS 23 September 2014 — Supreme Court interpretation: unspecified arras default to confirmatorias.
STS 25 April 2018 — Supreme Court confirmation of Article 1454 express requirement for penitenciales.