Property law

Ibiza Rooftop Demolished: What Spain's Property Law Says

By José Ángel Soria Sánchez, lawyer (ICAIB 5971) · Published: · Updated:

Ibiza rooftop terrace with a pergola, barbecue and a sign reading Azotea común
José Ángel Soria | Lawyer · ICAIB 5971 | Updated: May 2026
A Balearic court has ordered the demolition of an unauthorized penthouse rooftop in Ibiza after the owner drilled through the building slab, locked out neighbours, and turned the space into a holiday rental. Under Spain's Horizontal Property Act, no individual owner can do this without unanimous community consent.
⚖ Legal Reference
Audiencia Provincial de Illes Balears — ruling upholding the first-instance judgment of the Juzgado de Primera Instancia de Ibiza. Legal basis: Arts. 7, 9, 10, and 17.6 of Spain's Ley de Propiedad Horizontal (LPH, Ley 49/1960, as amended).

What Actually Happened in Ibiza

The facts are straightforward — and surprisingly common in the Balearic Islands. A penthouse owner decided to expand upward by physically connecting their apartment to the communal rooftop directly above, drilling through the building's structural concrete slab without notifying, let alone obtaining consent from, the homeowners' association (comunidad de propietarios).

Once access was secured, the owner installed a private internal staircase, fitted a locked gate to block all other residents, and built a full outdoor amenity space: a brick barbecue with dedicated plumbing, an electrical network, and a custom pergola bolted to the building's perimeter walls. The space was then marketed as a premium holiday rental feature.

For a while, neighbours tolerated moderate rooftop use. The commercialization changed everything: parties, noise, and constant foot traffic directly above their ceilings. The community voted unanimously to go to court.

What Spain's Horizontal Property Act Prohibits Here

The rooftop belongs to everyone, not the penthouse owner

Under Art. 396 of the Spanish Civil Code and Art. 3 LPH, building envelopes — including rooftops, structural slabs, and load-bearing elements — are elementos comunes: common elements belonging collectively to all co-owners. Ownership of the penthouse does not confer any special right over the roof above it.

This is a point many foreign buyers in Mallorca and Ibiza misunderstand: being on the top floor is not the same as owning the top.

Structural modifications require unanimous consent

Art. 17.6 LPH establishes that any act affecting common structural elements requires prior approval by unanimous vote of the community meeting (junta de propietarios). Drilling through a concrete slab qualifies unambiguously. Bypassing that vote converted a renovation project into an unlawful act — regardless of the investment made.

Locking out other owners is a separate violation

Art. 9.1.a LPH obliges every owner to respect common elements and not impede other owners' legitimate use of them. Installing a lock on the rooftop gate is a clear breach of the statute, independently of the structural work.

Risk Assessment: Common Unauthorized Actions in Co-Owned Buildings

Action Legal Issue Consent Required Risk
Drilling through structural slab Modification of common structural element (Art. 17.6 LPH) Unanimous vote HIGH — Demolition order
Locking communal rooftop or terrace Impeding access to common area (Art. 9 LPH) Unanimous vote HIGH — Court injunction
Installing BBQ / pergola on communal roof Exclusive appropriation of common element Unanimous vote HIGH — Removal + costs
Tourist rental causing persistent nuisance Art. 7.2 LPH (notoriously harmful activity) 3/5 majority to cease MEDIUM-HIGH
Internal renovation within private unit Generally permitted if no structural impact Notification advisable LOW
Air conditioning unit on facade Affects common element (facade) Simple majority (Art. 17.2) MEDIUM
Practical Criterion Does the work affect an element any other owner could legitimately use, or that contributes to the physical integrity of the building? If yes, you need community consent before you start — not after. Retroactive ratification is legally possible in theory but extremely difficult once neighbours have lodged a complaint.

The Court's Order: No Room for Negotiation

Both courts rejected the owner's defence and ordered three specific obligations:

  1. Immediate cessation of all exclusive private use of the rooftop.
  2. Full demolition of every installation — pergola, barbecue, staircase, plumbing, and electrical network — at the owner's expense.
  3. Structural restoration of the building slab using materials of equivalent quality, also at the owner's expense.

The financial exposure is substantial: demolition, restoration, the community's legal costs, and the owner's own defence — on top of the investment already made in installations that must now be torn out.

Why This Matters Beyond Ibiza

This ruling is not an isolated Balearic outcome. The legal framework is identical throughout Spain. Foreign buyers are disproportionately affected for a simple reason: in many northern European countries, the top-floor flat customarily includes rights over the roof space. Spanish law does not work this way. The escritura de división horizontal governs what is private and what is common — and if the rooftop is listed as a common element, no individual owner can change that without unanimous community approval.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a penthouse owner use the communal rooftop privately if no one objects?
Tolerance by neighbours does not create a legal right. Under the LPH, common elements cannot be appropriated by individual use, no matter how long that use continues. Courts have consistently held that passive acquiescence does not convert de facto occupation into a legitimate entitlement. The moment the community decides to act — which it can do at any time — the occupying owner has no legal defence based on prior tolerance alone.
What vote percentage is needed to authorize rooftop modifications in Spain?
Art. 17.6 LPH requires a unanimous vote of all owners for any modification affecting structural or envelope elements — including the rooftop slab. This means 100% of co-owners must agree, including absent owners who do not oppose within 30 days of receiving the minutes. Simple or qualified majorities are insufficient. In practice, unanimous consent for structural rooftop modifications is very difficult to obtain, which is why prior legal advice is essential before any such project.
Can I negotiate rooftop access rights before buying a penthouse in Mallorca or Ibiza?
Yes — but it must be done correctly and before completion. The only lawful way to convert a common rooftop into a private-use area is through a formal modification of the título constitutivo, requiring unanimous consent from all co-owners and registration at the Land Registry. A side agreement with the selling owner alone is not sufficient. If exclusive rooftop access is a material term of your purchase, a property lawyer must verify the legal status and manage any community approval process before contracts are exchanged.
Can a holiday rental licence be revoked because of nuisance to the community?
This is a two-track issue. On the civil side, Art. 7.2 LPH allows a community to seek a court injunction ordering an owner to cease an activity that is notoriously harmful — a 3/5 majority vote is required to authorise the legal action. On the administrative side, regional tourist authorities in the Balearic Islands can suspend or revoke a holiday rental licence if the activity causes persistent nuisance. The Ibiza ruling engaged both dimensions simultaneously, which is what made the outcome particularly severe.
Who pays for demolition and restoration when an unauthorised structure is ordered removed?
The owner who carried out the unlawful works bears the full cost of demolition, removal, and structural restoration — including restoring the building to its original state using materials of equivalent quality. The community's legal costs in obtaining the ruling may also be recoverable against the offending owner depending on the court's cost allocation order. There is no insurance mechanism that typically covers these liabilities; they fall entirely on the individual responsible.
Does Spain's new MASC requirement (LO 1/2025) affect how communities pursue these cases?
Since April 2025, LO 1/2025 introduced mandatory pre-litigation mediation or ADR (MASC) as a procedural requirement for most civil claims, including horizontal property disputes. Communities must now attempt a recognised form of alternative dispute resolution before filing a court claim. For urgent situations involving ongoing structural damage, precautionary measures can still be requested from the court directly. Any community facing a similar situation should take legal advice promptly to comply with the current pre-litigation requirements.

How I Can Help You

Whether you own property in Mallorca or Ibiza, sit on a community board, or are considering purchasing a penthouse with rooftop access — I can advise you on your exact legal position under Spain's Horizontal Property Act.

Schedule a 30-Minute Consultation

30-minute initial consultation: €200, VAT included.

You pay when you book, by card (Stripe), in the Cal.com calendar. You get an invoice. If I cannot take your matter, I refund the amount. How we use your data: privacy policy.

Sources Consulted
  • Ley 49/1960, de 21 de julio, sobre Propiedad Horizontal (LPH) — consolidated text via BOE.es
  • Arts. 396 and 553 of the Spanish Civil Code (Código Civil)
  • LO 1/2025, de 2 de enero, de medidas en materia de eficiencia del Servicio Público de Justicia (MASC) — BOE núm. 2, 3 January 2025
  • Audiencia Provincial de Illes Balears — ruling upholding first-instance judgment, Juzgado de Primera Instancia de Ibiza
  • CENDOJ — Tribunal Supremo jurisprudence on Art. 17.6 LPH and common elements, accessed May 2026

Last reviewed: May 2026. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Book a consultation · €200