Wealth planning

UK Property Owners in Spain: How to Claim Back Tax You've Been Overpaying Since Brexit

Published:

Premium law office in Palma de Mallorca overlooking the Mediterranean — Estudio Legal Soria, specialist in non-resident property tax for UK owners in Spain

If you own property in Mallorca or anywhere in Spain and you're a UK resident who has been renting it out, there's a reasonable chance you've been overpaying Spanish tax since Brexit — and a July 2025 court ruling has opened a window to get it back. That window closes in stages. The last chance to reclaim overpaid tax from 2022 expires at the end of 2026.

José Ángel Soria — Lawyer, ICAIB 5971 | Estudio Legal Soria, Palma de Mallorca | June 2026

What changed: On 28 July 2025, Spain's National Court (Audiencia Nacional) ruled in SAN 3630/2025 that non-EU residents — including UK owners post-Brexit — have the right to deduct rental expenses when calculating Spanish non-resident income tax (IRNR). This right was previously reserved for EU/EEA residents only. The ruling opens the door to refunds for overpaid tax in 2022, 2023, 2024, and 2025. The case is pending potential appeal to the Supreme Court, but the National Court's position is clear and actionable now.

The Tax You've Been Paying — and Why It Was Higher Than It Should Have Been

Every non-resident who owns property in Spain must file a Spanish tax return each year, using a form called Modelo 210. This applies whether your property is rented out, used as a holiday home, or sitting empty. The Spanish tax authorities don't distinguish: owning a property here creates a tax obligation.

For rental income, what you pay depends on where you live. Until July 2025, the rules worked like this:

Your tax residence Tax rate Expense deductions allowed?
EU / EEA resident (e.g. Germany, France, Norway) 19% on net income Yes — mortgage interest, repairs, community fees, insurance, IBI, management costs
UK resident (post-Brexit, treated as non-EU) 24% on gross income No — tax was calculated on total rental receipts before any costs
US, Canadian, other non-EU residents 24% on gross income No — same position as UK

Those two differences — the higher rate and the inability to deduct costs — meant a UK owner renting out a Mallorca apartment could easily be paying double what a German owner of the same property would pay. For a property generating €20,000 in annual rental income with €6,000 in legitimate costs, the gap between the EU and UK tax bill was typically over €3,000 per year.

Same property. Same rental income. Before July 2025 ruling After July 2025 ruling
German owner (EU) 19% on net income
Deductions allowed
19% on net income
No change
UK owner (post-Brexit) 24% on gross income
No deductions
24% on net income
Deductions now allowed — and refundable back to 2022
US / Canadian owner 24% on gross income
No deductions
24% on net income
Same improvement as UK owners

Before Brexit, UK residents enjoyed EU treatment. Since January 2021, they have been taxed as third-country nationals. Most UK owners were never told this changed — their gestoría or property manager filed the Modelo 210, used the 24% rate on gross income as the law required, and nobody questioned it. Because it was the correct interpretation of the law as it stood.

What the July 2025 Ruling Actually Says

The case that changed this involved a US resident who owned a rental property in Barcelona. The Spanish Tax Agency refused to allow her to deduct any rental costs when calculating her IRNR. She appealed, and the National Court sided with her.

The court's reasoning was straightforward: the restriction on expense deductions for non-EU residents violates Article 63 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFUE), which prohibits restrictions on the free movement of capital — not just within the EU, but also between EU member states and third countries. Spain's discriminatory treatment of non-EU landlords, the court ruled, had no valid legal justification.

The judgment (SAN 3630/2025, ECLI:ES:AN:2025:3630, Section 2 of the National Court's Administrative Chamber, 28 July 2025) annulled both the Tax Agency's refusal and the Central Economic-Administrative Tribunal's confirmation of it.

The practical result: non-EU residents — including UK owners since Brexit — are entitled to deduct the same rental expenses as EU residents, and can claim refunds for the excess tax paid in years that have not yet prescribed. Four years back from now means 2022 is still open — but only until the end of 2026.

What You Can Claim Back, and How Far Back

Spanish tax law allows you to request a correction of a prior self-assessment (rectificación de autoliquidación) within four years of the filing deadline. For most UK owners who filed Modelo 210 on gross rental income for 2022, the prescription deadline falls around January 2027. In practice, the safe window to act is before the end of 2026.

Tax year Standard filing deadline Prescription (4-year limit) Claimable in 2026?
2022 20 January 2023 ~January 2027 Yes — act before end of 2026
2023 20 January 2024 ~January 2028 Yes
2024 20 January 2025 ~January 2029 Yes
2025 20 January 2026 ~January 2030 Yes — deadline 31 Dec 2026 for imputed income

The expenses you can claim back against are those directly connected to generating the rental income: mortgage interest on the Spanish property, repair and maintenance costs, community fees (gastos de comunidad), property insurance, IBI (the local council property tax), property management fees, and depreciation on the building and fixtures. Every item needs documented evidence — Spanish invoices (facturas), bank statements, IBI receipts.

A worked example

Sarah owns a two-bedroom apartment in Palma's old town. She rents it out on a long-term basis and has been filing Modelo 210 every January since Brexit through her property manager. Her numbers for a typical year:

Amount
Annual rental income €18,000
Mortgage interest (Spanish bank) €3,200
IBI (local property tax) €640
Community fees €900
Property management fees €1,080
Insurance + repairs €580
Total deductible expenses €6,400
What she paid (gross, 24%) What she should have paid (net, 24%)
Taxable base €18,000 €11,600 (€18,000 − €6,400)
Tax due at 24% €4,320 €2,784
Overpayment per year €1,536

Over four years (2022–2025), that is €6,144 before statutory interest. Not every case will produce this figure — it depends entirely on your rental income and documented costs — but for any UK owner with a mortgage on a Spanish rental property, the numbers are likely to be meaningful.

The SAN 3630/2025 ruling is significant, but it is not the final word. The Spanish Tax Agency or the State Legal Service (Abogacía del Estado) can appeal to the Supreme Court, and the outcome there is not guaranteed. Several tax specialists have noted that the National Court's position rests on solid EU law grounds — the same Article 63 TFUE argument has been used to extend non-discriminatory treatment in inheritance tax cases, and the TJUE itself has reinforced this line in 2023 — but until the Supreme Court confirms the approach, there remains legal uncertainty.

The second caveat concerns the tax rate itself. The ruling addresses expense deductions, not the 24% rate that applies to UK residents versus 19% for EU nationals. Separate proceedings are underway challenging that rate differential, but they have not yet produced a binding ruling. The refund calculation in this article is based on the expense deduction element only.

How the Refund Process Works in Practice

  1. 1
    Gather your documentation. You need: the Modelo 210 filings submitted for each year you want to claim (your fiscal representative or gestoría should have copies), the original IBI receipts showing the cadastral value, and invoices for all deductible expenses — repairs, insurance, management fees, community fees, mortgage interest statements from your Spanish bank.
  2. 2
    Calculate the overpayment. For each year: recalculate the tax due on net income (gross rental receipts minus deductible expenses) at 24%, and compare it to what was actually paid on gross income at 24%. The difference, plus statutory interest, is what you can claim.
  3. 3
    File the rectificación de autoliquidación. This is a formal correction request submitted to the AEAT, one per tax year, through the Sede Electrónica. It requires a professional digital certificate — you cannot do this without a fiscal representative or lawyer with AEAT access.
  4. 4
    Wait for the AEAT's response. The Tax Agency typically has six months to respond. They may request additional documentation. If the claim is rejected — which remains possible while the Supreme Court has not confirmed the ruling — you have the option to appeal through the administrative and judicial route.
  5. 5
    Receive the refund. If accepted, the AEAT transfers the amount to a designated Spanish bank account. Timeline from filing to payment typically runs three to nine months depending on the volume of claims the Agency is processing.

The key distinction here is between a filing service and a lawyer. Platforms that handle Modelo 210 compliance can file the annual return, but the rectificación process — particularly if the AEAT challenges it — requires representation by a qualified lawyer with fiscal mandate. That is a different service.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does this apply to me if I only use the property personally and don't rent it out?

Not for this specific refund claim — the July 2025 ruling addresses rental income and the right to deduct rental expenses. If your property is used personally, you file Modelo 210 for imputed income (renta imputada), calculated at a percentage of the cadastral value. A separate challenge before the European Commission questions whether Spain is right to impose this tax on non-residents at all, but as of June 2026, the rule still applies and you must continue to file. The personal-use Modelo 210 for the 2025 tax year is due by 31 December 2026.

I rented my property for part of the year and used it personally for the rest. Can I still claim?

Yes, for the rental portion. In a split year, you file two Modelo 210 returns: one for the rental income periods (declaring actual rental receipts) and one for the personal-use periods (imputed income on the non-rented days, calculated proportionally from the cadastral value). The refund claim applies only to the rental income filings, where the expense deduction argument applies. The imputed income portion is a separate calculation and the ruling does not directly change it.

What if my gestoría or property manager filed the Modelo 210 on my behalf? Can I still claim?

Yes. The fact that someone else filed on your behalf doesn't affect your entitlement to claim a correction. You are the taxpayer; the filing was made in your name. You will need copies of those filings — your gestoría should be able to provide them — and the supporting documentation for expenses in the relevant years. In some cases, your property manager may have records of management fees and maintenance costs that can be used as evidence.

Is this affected by the UK–Spain Double Taxation Agreement?

The UK–Spain DTA remains in force and prevents double taxation on the same income — Spanish rental tax paid can be credited against your UK tax liability on the same income. The DTA also contains a non-discrimination clause (Article 25), which some advisers have cited alongside the TFUE Article 63 argument as additional support for the refund claim. Whether the AEAT accepts this reasoning is not yet settled, but it strengthens the overall legal position. Your UK accountant should be aware of any refund received from Spain, as it may affect your UK tax credit calculation for those years.

What happens if the Supreme Court overturns the National Court ruling while my claim is being processed?

This is the main risk to understand before proceeding. If the Supreme Court reverses the National Court's position, claims already filed may be rejected and any refunds already paid could theoretically be reclaimed by the AEAT, though in practice this would be unusual for completed transactions. The legal community's assessment is that the TJUE's own 2023 judgment on the same Article 63 TFUE principles makes reversal unlikely — but "unlikely" is not "impossible." Filing the claim is not risk-free, and the decision should be made with a clear understanding of that uncertainty.

How much could I realistically recover?

It depends on your rental income, your documented expenses, and how many years you can claim. For a property generating €15,000–€25,000 in annual rental income with typical costs of €4,000–€8,000 per year, the overpayment per year falls roughly in the range of €960–€1,920 (the 24% rate applied to the expenses that should have been deductible). Over four years, that is a range of €3,840–€7,680 before statutory interest. Properties with higher rents or significant mortgage interest will have proportionally larger claims. The only way to know your specific figure is to run the calculation against your actual filings and documented costs.

José Ángel Soria — How I Can Help You

My background includes investment banking, in derivatives, at Goldman Sachs (New York) and Deutsche Bank (London), and a spell at American Express (Madrid). When I look at a non-resident tax structure, I have in mind international clients who were simply never told how the Spanish system works against them.

If you've been renting out a property in Mallorca since Brexit and filing on gross income, this is worth examining before the 2022 window closes. I'll tell you whether a claim makes sense in your case, what the realistic recovery looks like, and what risks you're accepting — before you commit to anything.

Book a 30-Minute Consultation

30-minute initial consultation: €200, VAT included.

You pay when you book, by card (Stripe), in the Cal.com calendar. You get an invoice. If I cannot take your matter, I refund the amount. How we use your data: privacy policy.

Sources consulted for this article:

SAN 3630/2025, ECLI:ES:AN:2025:3630 — Audiencia Nacional, Sección Segunda de lo Contencioso-Administrativo, 28 July 2025, recurso 636/2021 (IRNR rental expense deductions, non-EU residents)

Real Decreto Legislativo 5/2004 (TRLIRNR), art. 24 — Base imponible, rentas obtenidas sin mediación de establecimiento permanente

Ley 35/2006 (LIRPF), art. 23 — Gastos deducibles rendimientos del capital inmobiliario (applied by reference for EU/EEA non-residents under TRLIRNR art. 24.6)

Tratado de Funcionamiento de la Unión Europea (TFUE), art. 63 — Libre circulación de capitales (fundamento de la SAN 3630/2025)

TJUE, sentencia de 12 de octubre de 2023, C-670/21, ECLI:EU:C:2023:763 — libre circulación de capitales con terceros Estados (citada en SAN 3630/2025)

Convenio entre España y el Reino Unido para evitar la doble imposición (Londres, 14 de marzo de 2013, BOE 15/05/2014), art. 25 — No discriminación

Ley 58/2003, General Tributaria, art. 66 — Plazo de prescripción (4 años)

Last reviewed: June 2026

This article reflects the law and case law as it stood in June 2026. The SAN 3630/2025 ruling is subject to potential appeal to the Supreme Court, which could modify the position described here. Nothing in this article constitutes legal advice on your specific situation — a personal consultation is the only way to assess whether a claim is appropriate in your case.

JAS
José Ángel Soria
Lawyer — ICAIB 5971, Ilustre Colegio de Abogados de las Islas Baleares
Written and reviewed personally — Estudio Legal Soria, Palma de Mallorca
Book a consultation · €200