Property law

Hidden Defects in Spanish Property: The 6-Month Deadline and What May Pause It

Published: · Updated:

Lawyer in a grey suit advising a woman at a table with a view of Palma marina and cathedral

José Ángel Soria, lawyer, ICAIB 5971
Estudio Legal Soria, Palma de Mallorca · Updated: November 2026
General information, no lawyer-client relationship

The Civil Code gives you six months from delivery to act on a hidden defect, and a letter of complaint does not stop that clock. Since 2025, a written request to negotiate may pause it, a rule that is new and untested for this deadline.

If you found a defect a few months after completing, do four things this week: do not repair anything, instruct an independent technical expert, send the seller a written request to negotiate that you can prove was sent, and put a filing date in your diary before month six. Timing is the first thing I would check in any of these cases, before the defect itself.

Situation as of 16 November 2026.

  • Since 3 April 2025, article 5 of Organic Law 1/2025 makes a prior attempt at out-of-court settlement (known as MASC) a condition for a civil claim to be admitted. Article 7 sets out what that attempt does to deadlines.
  • Under article 7.1, a request to the other party to open negotiations, which defines the object of the negotiation, suspends a forfeiture period from the date of the attempt to deliver it to the other party. It ends when an agreement is signed or the negotiation ends. The count resumes if there is no first meeting, or no written reply within 30 calendar days of receipt. It also resumes if a concrete offer goes unanswered for 30 days.
  • If a mediator takes part, article 7.2.a refers to article 4 of Law 5/2012 on mediation. If a conciliator takes part, article 7.2.b applies: the suspension runs from the conciliator's receipt of the request, and the count resumes after 15 calendar days if the conciliator does not try to contact the other party, or if there is no first meeting or written reply within 15 days of the other party's receipt of the proposal. A notary or registrar acting as conciliator falls under the Voluntary Jurisdiction Act (Law 15/2015), applied as a fallback (art. 7.2.d).
  • Article 7.3 adds a separate deadline: if the request gets no answer, or the negotiation ends without agreement, the claim must be filed within one year of receipt or of the end of the negotiation.
  • I have found no judgment applying article 7 to the six months of article 1490 of the Civil Code. The plenary Supreme Court judgment 173/2026 of 5 February concerns a different forfeiture period, the one-year maritime period. It holds that the period cannot be interrupted by one party, and adds, in passing, that this is without prejudice to the suspension of a forfeiture period by a request to negotiate under article 7 of Organic Law 1/2025. That supports the reading below, but it is not a ruling on article 1490.
  • So everything below on pausing the clock is my reading of the text. Until courts apply it to this period, I would treat the six months as real: send the request early and keep a claim ready to file.

Why Spanish purchases have no built-in survey

In England a building survey before exchange is normal. In Spain no equivalent step is built into the purchase. There is no standard seller's condition report. The notary checks title and reads out the deed, and does not inspect the building. Your lawyer checks planning, debts and charges, and not the physical state of the structure unless that is part of the job you set. An agent's duties depend on what the agent was engaged to do and what they told you.

So buyers who would never exchange in England without a survey sign in Mallorca after a few viewings. When a defect appears months later, many assume there is no remedy. There is one, but it is short.

What does Spanish law count as a hidden defect?

Article 1484 of the Civil Code makes the seller answer for hidden defects that make the property unfit for its use, or reduce that use so much that the buyer would not have bought it, or would have paid less. The seller is not liable for visible defects. Nor for hidden ones if the buyer is an expert who, by profession, should easily have spotted them, which matters if you are an architect or a builder. In practice three things have to hold:

  • Hidden. Not apparent to a careful buyer on an ordinary inspection. The usual dispute: the seller says it was visible, the buyer says it was covered by new finishes.
  • Already there. It existed at delivery, even if it showed later. This comes from the case law and not from the wording of article 1484. The usual dispute: the seller says it appeared after completion, and an expert has to date it.
  • Serious. It makes the property unfit for its use, or lowers that use enough to change the buyer's decision or price. The usual dispute: the seller says it is cosmetic, and the buyer's expert puts a figure on it.

When a renovation hides the defect

A typical example: a villa with years of deferred maintenance (damp rising in the foundations, movement in a load-bearing wall, a failing drain) is renovated cosmetically before it is listed. New floors, fresh paint, a new kitchen. It photographs well and sells fast, and the defect sits under the new finish.

The seller's answer is nearly always the same: "I renovated the whole house, I would have seen it." That answer weakens when an expert shows that the damage is older than the works and that the works covered it. It also bears on what the seller knew, which matters for the remedy you can claim (below).

What stops the six months, and what does not?

Article 1490 says the actions for hidden defects expire six months from delivery of the thing sold. The Supreme Court treats this as a forfeiture period (caducidad), not a limitation period (STS 41/2009, 22 January), counts it from actual delivery of the keys, and counts it from date to date, so a claim filed one day late was barred. A forfeiture period does not restart because you complained. The 2025 reform is the first thing that may suspend it. See the dated box for its limits. These points decide whether a request works:

  1. It has to define the object of the negotiation. "I am unhappy about the house" is a complaint. "I claim a price reduction or rescission for the defects in the drainage and ground-floor slab described in the attached report, and I propose to negotiate" is a request.
  2. It has to reach the seller in a way you can prove. The law looks at the date of the attempt to communicate it, to the seller's home or workplace, or by the electronic channel you already used with them. A registered letter or a notarial notice is easier to prove than an email.
  3. The clock resumes if the seller ignores it. The rules are in the dated box.
  4. It does not replace the claim. If the negotiation fails, you still have to file inside what remains of the six months, and within the one-year limit of article 7.3.

Do not repair before you document. A buyer sees damp in month two, calls a plumber, patches it and waits. It returns in month seven. The period has run, and the patch has destroyed the evidence of where the damage came from. Instruct a technical expert before a tradesman.

What can you claim?

Article 1486 gives you a choice between two actions: withdraw from the contract, with the expenses you paid reimbursed, or keep the property and recover a proportional part of the price, fixed by experts. The seller is liable even if they did not know about the defect (art. 1485). If the seller did know and did not tell you, you also get damages, but on the text of the article only if you choose to rescind.

  • Rescission (acción redhibitoria, art. 1486 CC). Six months from delivery. The property goes back and you recover the price and the expenses you paid, plus damages if the seller knew.
  • Price reduction (quanti minoris, art. 1486 CC). Six months from delivery. You keep the property and recover a proportional part of the price, fixed by experts.
  • Non-performance (aliud pro alio, arts. 1101 and 1124 CC). Five years (art. 1964.2 CC). Rescission and damages, if the property is so unfit that it is not what was sold.

The "as seen" clause is not the barrier it looks like. Article 1485 lets the parties agree otherwise, but only protects a seller who did not know about the defects. A clause cannot cover a defect the seller knew about and hid.

The third route is the fallback if the six months have gone. The threshold is high. In STS 364/2009, 14 May (appeal 477/2004), a case on a different fact pattern (an urban reclassification after the sale), the Supreme Court refused to apply it because the buyer got the same property, which could still be used. A structural failure that makes the building unsafe to live in is a candidate. A leaking shower is not. Plead it in the alternative and do not plan around it.

As an example, imagine a couple who buy a renovated five-bedroom villa near Andratx for €1,850,000. In month two, damp appears on the ground floor. They instruct an architect, who opens the floor and finds a drain that has been failing for years under the slab. The works that covered it were done before the sale. His report puts the repair at €210,000, and a surveyor agrees the defect lowers the value of the villa by the same amount.

Take two versions. In the first, they send a request to negotiate in month 4, with the report in hand and nothing repaired. In the second, they patch the damp twice and only act in month 8.

Request sentRoutes that may be openAmount in dispute
Month 4Rescission or price reduction, plus damages if rescinding and the seller's knowledge can be proved€210,000, about 11% of the price, assuming experts fix the reduction at that figure
Month 8Only non-performanceThe same €210,000, but a court is unlikely to find the villa is not what was sold if they live in it

The figures are illustrative, not based on a real matter and not a forecast. The amount in dispute is not an amount you would recover, and recovery is not assured. It depends on the expert's valuation and on proof of what the seller knew.

The difference between the two versions is the routes still open, not a prediction of the outcome.

What the expert report has to prove

Without a sound technical report, there is no claim. It has to show three things: that the defect existed before delivery, that an ordinary inspection would not have found it, and that it is serious enough for the remedy asked for. A report that describes today's damage and says nothing about its age is of little use.

It also has to hold up against the seller's expert, whose job is to say the defect appeared after delivery or was plainly visible. The first expert to call is a structural architect or building pathologist, not the tradesman who will fix it. One dates and documents the damage. The other repairs it and, in doing so, removes the evidence. If you live abroad, the expert and the request can be handled remotely through a lawyer, but the request should be in Spanish.

If you find a serious defect, I would get the report first, send the request to negotiate in the form article 7.1 describes, and keep the claim ready to file anyway. The later you send it, the less margin you keep if a court rejects the suspension.

This is a general view, not advice for your case. It depends on the date of delivery, the contract and what the seller knew.

Frequently asked questions

Does the six-month period run from the notarial signing or from receiving the keys?

Article 1490 counts from delivery of the thing sold, and the Supreme Court has counted it from actual delivery. That normally coincides with the deed and the handover of keys. If the deed was signed but possession was deferred, the period starts with actual possession. If you are unsure of the date, treat the earlier one as the start.

The contract says the property is sold "as seen". Can I still claim?

Possibly. Article 1485 lets the parties exclude the seller's liability, but the exclusion protects only a seller who did not know about the defects. If the seller knew and hid it, the clause does not help them. Proving that knowledge is the hard part, and a renovation that covered the defect can be evidence of it.

Does a letter to the seller stop the six months?

A letter that only complains does not. A written request to open negotiations that defines what is claimed, and that you can prove was sent, may suspend the period under article 7.1 of Organic Law 1/2025. The count resumes if the seller does not reply in writing within 30 calendar days. How courts treat this for article 1490 is in the dated box, so keep the claim ready to file.

Is out-of-court settlement compulsory before I sue?

For most civil claims, yes. Article 5 of Organic Law 1/2025 makes a prior attempt a condition for admission of the claim. Negotiation directly between the parties or between their lawyers counts, provided the object of the negotiation and of the claim are the same. Keep proof of what you sent and when.

What if the seller is a developer or a business?

For a new building, the Building Regulation Act (LOE, art. 17) sets one year for finishing defects, for which the builder answers, and three years for defects affecting habitability and ten for structural ones, for which the agents who took part answer, counted from the acceptance of the works. The developer also answers jointly to buyers for construction defects (art. 17.3). The claim has to be brought within two years of the damage appearing (art. 18). These periods exist alongside the Civil Code ones. If the seller sold as a business and you bought as a consumer, consumer law may also apply. I have not assumed that for property, so check it for your case.

Can I claim against a surveyor I hired?

If you instructed a qualified surveyor and they missed a defect that a competent professional should have found, a claim against them may run alongside the one against the seller. If you did not hire one, you can still claim against the seller. Expect the seller's lawyers to say you should have.

José Ángel Soria: How I Can Help You

Almost 30 years of professional experience. My background includes investment banking, in derivatives, at Goldman Sachs (New York) and Deutsche Bank (London), and a spell at American Express (Madrid). If you think you have found a defect, the first thing we establish is the date of delivery, how many of the six months are left and what you can still send the seller. I will explain the steps and give you a fee estimate if you decide to proceed.

Book a 30-minute consultation (€200 VAT included)

If you then hire me for the work, the €200 is deducted from the total fee for that work. There is no obligation to hire me after the consultation. Bring the deed, the dates and any report or photos you have.

Please do not include confidential details of your case when booking. Controller: José Ángel Soria Sánchez (Estudio Legal Soria). Purpose: managing your booking. Legal basis: pre-contractual measures at your request (art. 6.1.b GDPR). Recipient: Cal.com, our calendar provider; any transfer outside the EEA is explained in the privacy policy. Retention, your rights and how to complain to the Spanish data authority (AEPD) are in the privacy policy.

Sources consulted for this article:

Spanish Civil Code, arts. 1101, 1124, 1484 to 1490 and 1964 (BOE-A-1889-4763)

Organic Law 1/2025, of 2 January, arts. 5 and 7, including the reference in art. 7.2 to art. 4 of Law 5/2012 on mediation (BOE-A-2025-76)

Law 38/1999 on Building Regulation (LOE), arts. 17 and 18 (BOE-A-1999-21567)

Supreme Court (Civil Chamber), judgment 41/2009 of 22 January (appeal 1213/2004; Roj STS 36/2009), on the forfeiture nature and how the six months are counted of the art. 1490 period

Supreme Court (Civil Chamber), judgment 364/2009 of 14 May (appeal 477/2004; Roj STS 2895/2009), on the limits of aliud pro alio (text published by El Notario del Siglo XXI)

Supreme Court (Civil Chamber, plenary), judgment 173/2026 of 5 February (appeal 8008/2021; Roj STS 341/2026), on the non-interruptible one-year maritime period and the suspension of forfeiture periods under art. 7 of Organic Law 1/2025

Last reviewed: 16 November 2026

This is general information based on the law on the date shown, not advice for your case. Reading this article does not create a lawyer-client relationship or guarantee any result. The forfeiture periods involved are short, and the law and its interpretation can change.

JAS
José Ángel Soria
Lawyer, member of the Ilustre Colegio de Abogados de las Islas Baleares (no. 5971)
Author and responsible lawyer. Estudio Legal Soria, Palma de Mallorca
Book a consultation · €200